More on Maybelline's Moisture Extreme Lip Liner

I know I am NOT the only one who finds more is better with makeup, polish, skincare, etc.  Why else would there be soooo many blogs like this one?

I posted here about getting three Maybelline lip liners at Big Lots this past week.  I loved them so much that I shopped at two different BL to see if there were more colors of this brand.  Maybelline's Moisture Extreme Lip Liner.  I'm in looooveeee!  

Yippee!  I was able to score two more different colors.

                                                Here's Cocoa and Toast.

And here is how it looks over 2 hours later and at least two hand-washings.  Plus, I tried rubbing it off with my index finger to boot.

                                               Light from a sunny window.

                                                Here's a look with outside light.

                               (Eeps!  I notice that even the freckles [that's the story I'm sticking to] show                                   up in macro shots.)

And now, 6 hours later, more hand-washings and cooking up a dinner.  Just in case you have doubt, I do wash the back of my hands!  I'm using hand soap and dish soap.  

I was so impressed with the first three, I had to get more.  I'm sure you understand. :)

Now if I could just find a pink shade, I could throw away all other liners.  But then that wouldn't be much fun, would it?

                                            Libby's fun.  She has permanent 'pinky' lips.

What's it take for you to say 'good-bye' to cosmetics you've used?  Have you had any new cosmetic discoveries yourself?